- The Investors Collaborative Newsletter
- Posts
- Credit Crunch may be looming, Dominoes are falling
Credit Crunch may be looming, Dominoes are falling
The Hard Road Newsletter
Happy Easter everyone! Hope your feast was delicious, your family healthy, and your portfolios green!
Now that we’ve apparently passed the point of everyone caring about banks collapsing, the Bulls have taken the market well above the 4000 mark, for seemingly no reason beyond “Nothing bad is happening, and the JPow is gonna have to pivot!” The $300 Billion of liquidity they pumped in about a month ago probably helped a little bit too, if we’re being honest.
Just like that, months of QT undone.
I’m not what you’d call a Bear, but this rally doesn’t seem to have any logical reason to be happening, for a couple reasons. Lets discuss.
Credit Crunch
Logically, the next domino in the chain of crises is credit. You raise interest rates and tighten monetary policy, credit becomes more risky, lending requirements increase, lending becomes more scarce and expensive. We’re currently watching the “Credit becomes risky” domino tip into the next, wondering if it has the momentum to keep the chain going. Lets check out the word on the street.
bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
From the story ..
bank lending contracted by the most on record in the last two weeks of March, indicating a tightening of credit conditions in the wake of several high-profile bank collapses that risks damaging the economy.
The pullback in total… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
— Jim Bianco biancoresearch.eth (@biancoresearch)
5:07 AM • Apr 8, 2023
The above thread has a couple graphs in it that paint a very detailed picture of the situation we’re currently in. Bank deposits are down and have been trending that way for months.
The less money banks have, the less they can lend.
The less they can lend, the harder they are to get.
The harder they are to get, the less businesses can grow.
APOLLO: “The credit crunch has started. .. A survey of 71 banks in the Dallas Fed district done after SVB went under shows a dramatic reversal in loan volumes, .. from March 21 to 29.” [Slok]
$KRE $XLF
— Carl Quintanilla (@carlquintanilla)
11:13 AM • Apr 6, 2023
And there we have it, loan volume is rapidly approaching the same levels as the beginning of Covid Lockdowns.
So thats what usually happens, interesting…
Not a pretty picture to be painting. Lets feed that confirmation bias with some more pretty graphs and anecdotes.
The S&P500 rally is blinding investors to the dangers of tightening lending standards
It’s a major economic warning signal
A thread 🧵 http
— Game of Trades (@GameofTrades_)
6:30 PM • Apr 6, 2023
This is big. Capital One is pulling inventory lines of credit (aka ‘floorplans’) on dealers 😳
Basically means its dealers have 90 days to refi their inventory.
From source: “Cap one is completely getting out of the inventory lending game”
[Reposted for added confidentiality]
— CarDealershipGuy (@GuyDealership)
2:02 PM • Apr 9, 2023
Commercial Real Estate?
Now that I’m well and truly uncertain of what comes next, lets look at what might be further down the chain. I mentioned this topic a few weeks ago in this newsletter linked below.
If you click no other link in this newsletter, please watch the below video!
This is an excellent overview of both CRE concerns and the liquidity in the banking system.
The bottom line is you can’t quantify the losses in CRE.
As a result, the banks just won’t lend to Main St as they try and protect themselves.
Credit is going to tighten big time
— QE Infinity (@StealthQE4)
11:35 AM • Apr 6, 2023
The quick hits -
Biggest spike in Fed Discount Window borrowing since 2008
Banks can’t make new loans because they’re desperate for liquidity.
~$20 Trillion of CRE loans currently exist, ~$270 Billion are coming due for refinance in the coming months.
The average total assets of the banks holding these loans in ~$250 Billion each.
Unrealized losses on these CRE loans are not visible yet, because those markets are much more dynamic and less liquid meaning the assets have not been re-priced with changes in demand.
Want some more anecdotes? I got you.
A scary story:
- Blackstone buys these in 2014
- Class A office towers in Cali
- Sold days ago at 36% discountIf this is happening with Class A office in Santa Ana, what's next for Class B/C...
— Aleksey Chernobelskiy (@chernobelskiy)
5:19 PM • Apr 9, 2023
Lets not assume that average joes like you and me are immune from these problems.
IMO - A potential Catalyst in coming 6-9 months could be a "Credit Crunch"
Imagine a person owes 8500 on a credit card. Card limit is 9000.
Due to Uncertainty, banks can say "your limit will be reduced to 7000. Pay 1500 immediately to keep using your card."
This is Not a joke
— Larry Cheung, CFA (@LarryCheungCFA)
11:13 PM • Apr 4, 2023
A picture that leaves little in the way of interpretation.
— Danielle DiMartino Booth (@DiMartinoBooth)
12:42 PM • Apr 7, 2023
That’s gonna do it for this week!
We’ve got a big one ahead of us, lots of data coming this week. Stay safe out there!
HUGE WEEK AHEAD
CPI ON WEDNESDAY
PPI ON THURSDAY
FOMC MEETING MINUTES ALSO THURSDAY
EARNINGS OF THE BIGGEST BANKS INCLUDING JP MORGAN, WELLS FARGO & CITIGROUP ON FRIDAY
$JPM $WFC $C
— GURGAVIN (@gurgavin)
5:01 PM • Apr 9, 2023
Wanna come hang out in the bear cave with me? Join us over on Discord!
Please note that the information provided is for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be financial advice. The information provided is not a substitute for professional advice and should not be relied upon as such. Always consult a financial advisor before making any financial decisions. Additionally, The Hard Road staff and contributors may have a stake in the Securities, Cryptocurrencies, Platforms, and other assets that are mentioned in this article and others.
We recently upgraded our subscription on Beehiiv, and now we can add polls!
What keeps you reading my ramblings? |
Reply